By Months: Helir-Valdor Seeder
Total Months: 11
Fully Profiled: 11
12.2024
53 Speeches
The speaker demonstrates thorough knowledge of the Riigikogu Rules of Procedure and Internal Rules Act, citing precise provisions and procedural precedents. They are an expert in the field of the Citizenship Act, presenting detailed statistics regarding the practices of previous governments and referencing relevant court rulings. Furthermore, they are well-versed in the financing and administrative structures pertaining to education and regional policy.
11.2024
89 Speeches
The speaker exhibits strong expertise in the details of the Riigikogu Rules of Procedure and Internal Rules Act and the budget procedure, repeatedly protesting procedural violations. He/She is also competent in matters of regional policy and administrative division, criticizing the creation of artificial regions and supporting the role of counties. The speaker possesses deep knowledge of constitutional amendment procedures and historical context, especially in the debate on suffrage (e.g., comparison with Latvia in 1992).
10.2024
31 Speeches
The speaker demonstrates profound expertise in legislative procedures, budget methodology, and the restructuring of public administration. The criticism is especially detailed concerning the reallocation of ministerial portfolios (telecommunications, the Land and Spatial Planning Agency), highlighting the risk of duplication and fragmentation. Expertise in constitutional jurisprudence is also evident, underscoring the importance of requiring the State Secretary to have a legal background.
09.2024
24 Speeches
Shows deep knowledge of national defense planning (NATO out-of-cycle development) and the structural problems of the Defence League (shortage of instructors). Possesses detailed knowledge of migration statistics (net migration of 14,000, Tallinn demographics) and the history of tax policy (the emergence of the tax hump). Presents specific criticism in the field of regional policy and agriculture (lack of protection for fertile land), noting that the minister fails to grasp strategic problems.
07.2024
30 Speeches
The speaker demonstrates expertise in matters of taxation and the state budget, comparing Estonia's tax policy to those of Latvia and Lithuania, and demanding a detailed impact analysis segmented by target groups. Furthermore, the speaker is well-versed in the Riigikogu's rules of procedure and legislative processes, criticizing the unconstitutional linking of amendments and the presiding officer's inconsistent interpretation regarding parliamentary breaks. Attention is focused on the specific effects of regional policy and transport (public transport versus private vehicles).
06.2024
36 Speeches
The speaker demonstrates profound expertise regarding the Riigikogu Rules of Procedure and Internal Rules Act, repeatedly referencing specific sections (§ 107) and the competence of the Board. Furthermore, he/she is intimately familiar with the legal and regional policy implications of amendments to tax laws (car tax, pension tax, land tax), emphasizing the violation of the principle of legal certainty.
05.2024
54 Speeches
The speaker demonstrates deep expertise in the legislative process, repeatedly criticizing violations of good legislative practice and the Riigikogu Rules of Procedure and Internal Rules Act (e.g., the tacking of amendments). Furthermore, they are familiar with the details of tax policy (the sugar tax, income tax reform) and internal security risk analyses, citing KAPO reports and legal opinions concerning the issue of voting rights.
04.2024
29 Speeches
Demonstrates strong expertise in the procedural law and constitutionality of the Riigikogu, citing the standpoints of the Legal and Analysis Department and Supreme Court rulings. Possesses deep knowledge of electoral legislation, highlighting the Election Commission's remarks concerning technical and security risks related to voting using smart devices. Furthermore, they are familiar with social policy and demographic data, emphasizing the proportion of children who belong to large families.
03.2024
9 Speeches
The speaker exhibits profound expertise in the Riigikogu's rules of procedure, constitutional law, and procedural regulations. He disputes the interpretations put forth by the board and committees, particularly regarding the requirement for 51 votes and the established practice of bill rapporteurs, referencing both the constitution and specific legislation. Furthermore, he is well-versed in the specifics of the coalition agreement and the expert opinions issued by the Ministry of Justice concerning the suspension of suffrage.
02.2024
22 Speeches
Demonstrates profound expertise regarding the Riigikogu Rules of Procedure and Internal Rules Act and its annotated edition, challenging the Presidium's decisions concerning the return of interpellations and voting requirements. Shows thorough knowledge of migration policy regulations (EU, third countries, quotas) and references the Estonian Security Police (Kaitsepolitsei) yearbooks to emphasize security aspects. Criticizes the quality of draft legislation preparation, highlighting the absence of impact analyses and coordination tables.
01.2024
5 Speeches
The speaker demonstrates expertise in national finance and budget strategy (RES) issues, highlighting specific deficits and expenditures (e.g., 400 million, 1 billion, 26 million for public transport). They are also familiar with the details of the education reform, such as raising the mandatory school age and extending vocational education. Furthermore, they show procedural awareness by citing the referral of the Land Tax Act to the Supreme Court as a precedent.