By Plenary Sessions: Martin Helme

The speaker demonstrates expertise in public finance and tax policy, presenting specific data on the growth of national debt (in billions) and the severity of the economic recession. Technical terms such as "income deciles" are used, and the regressiveness of the tax system is analyzed to explain how tax hikes impact various income brackets. Furthermore, the speaker is knowledgeable about national defense funding scandals and the costs associated with major projects like Rail Baltic.

High level of expertise in public finance and macroeconomics, utilizing detailed data regarding budget deficit percentages and loan totals broken down by year. It relies on official sources (the Ministry of Finance, the Bank of Estonia) and statistical concepts (income deciles) to substantiate its critique. Demonstrates knowledge of the regressive effect of tax policy on various income groups.

The speaker demonstrates expertise in the fields of national defense and international maritime law, clearly distinguishing Estonia’s exclusive economic zone (EEZ) from its territorial waters and defining the boundaries of jurisdiction. Specific examples and names are cited, including the tanker Argent/Jaguar, Chief of the General Staff of the Defense Forces Vahur Karus, and former Navy Commander Jüri Saska. Furthermore, the speaker points to internal communication and operational errors within the government. The professional focus centers on operational readiness and the existence of action plans for handling security incidents.

Insufficient data

The speaker demonstrates expertise in national defense, citing specific government failures, such as shortfalls in defense funding and the inability to impede the shadow fleet. They emphasize the constitutional and security implications regarding the use of drones in Estonian airspace. This analysis is aimed at scrutinizing government activity and highlighting security risks.

The speaker demonstrates knowledge of financial management and conflicts of interest within the national defense sector, citing the State Audit Office audit and specific names (Heremid, Palmid, Salmid) in connection with the "revolving door" problem. Furthermore, they possess specific knowledge regarding the issuance of hunting permits and the division of responsibility between administrative jurisdictions concerning nuisance animals (wolves, bears).

The speaker demonstrates expertise in healthcare financial matters, citing the depletion of reserves, the magnitude of patient co-payments, and the lengthening of treatment waiting lists within the European context. Furthermore, the speaker is familiar with the legal nuances of administrative law and local elections legislation regarding residency requirements and registry entries. He utilizes detailed examples drawn from international political disputes (Biden, RFK Jr., COVID-19 narrative).

The speaker demonstrates expertise on national defense and security issues, referencing the National Audit Office's report concerning the misappropriation of funds, squandering, and general disorder within the defense sector. He/She is familiar with the technical limitations of drone detection (specifically, below 300 meters altitude) and the details regarding the history and financing of border construction. Furthermore, the speaker is knowledgeable about the nuances of tax policy, mentioning corporate tax revenue and the consideration of an automobile tax.

The speaker demonstrates a high level of detail regarding national defense topics, referencing specific incidents (the Ukrainian drone, the tanker) and issues within defense procurements (the lack of HIMARS ammunition and checks on operational readiness/usability). The conclusions of the National Audit Office are utilized in criticizing the government's management of defense spending, specifically mentioning the unaccounted movement of hundreds of millions of euros. Reference is also made to Colonel Karus's previous statements concerning airspace identification.

The speaker demonstrates a deep understanding of the Riigikogu's rules of procedure and procedural regulations, criticizing the decisions made by the Board (for instance, the arbitrary enforcement of the 51-vote requirement). Furthermore, he exhibits knowledge of the technical issues surrounding e-voting and the scale of the national surveillance system (PPA cameras), citing specific figures (20 million images per month). Detailed questions are also raised concerning the budgetary and demographic consequences of Ukraine joining the EU.