By Agendas: Yoko Alender

The speaker demonstrates expertise in the field of mineral resources and environmental law, detailing the multipurpose use of areas holding mining permits and the simplified procedure for the reclamation of peat mines. Specific terminology, such as "reclamation conditions" and "additional option," is employed, referencing the adequacy of the Environmental Board's oversight. The expertise lies in accurately conveying the technical discussions that took place within the commission.

The speaker demonstrates expertise at the intersection of environmental and energy policy, specifically addressing the feasibility of utilizing and marketing timber derived from conservation felling as renewable energy. The speaker references their awareness of officials' standpoints and the detailed discussions that took place within the environmental committee.

The speaker demonstrates comprehensive knowledge in the field of circular economy and waste management, particularly concerning the economic and technical aspects of battery and accumulator recycling. Specific data regarding the quantities of electronic waste is utilized (e.g., 20,000 tons of electronics placed on the market), and reference is made to European-level regulations, such as the Critical Raw Materials Regulation. The profitability of lead-acid battery recycling and the role of producer responsibility organizations are highlighted separately.

Data is scarce.

The speakers demonstrated a detailed awareness of waste management statistics and systemic issues, citing data on municipal waste generation (1 kg per day) and the recycling rate (38% in Estonia versus 48% in the EU). Specific technical aspects were also highlighted, such as the efficiency of sorting lines (with only 10% material recovery) and the necessity of digitalizing reporting, referencing observations made by the National Audit Office. Furthermore, they were knowledgeable about the proportion of waste generated by the oil shale industry (70%).

The speaker demonstrates authority in both the legislative process and the specific field of radiation protection. They emphasize that the subject matter is highly technical and understood by only a small number of people. This expertise is further substantiated by a comprehensive list of consulted experts, including dentists, the Radiology Society, the Medical Physics Society, and researchers from the Technical University.

The speaker demonstrates profound expertise in energy policy and wind farm regulations, differentiating the criteria for defining the impact zones of onshore versus offshore turbines (real impact versus local benefit). They utilize technical data, such as the differences in turbine capacities (7 MW onshore versus 15 MW offshore), and reference specific legal sections (§ 553). Furthermore, they are well-versed in frequency markets and the decoupling of the Estonian electricity system from Russia and Belarus.

The speaker demonstrates profound expertise in the field of environmental law and planning, utilizing precise terminology such as 'noise target value' and 'limit value'. They are capable of explaining the practical challenges of implementing the law, for instance, defining the scope of a developer's liability for traffic noise. Furthermore, the speaker references the role of the Ministry of Climate in refining measurement standards and the endorsement of the Chancellor of Justice's position.

The speaker demonstrates profound expertise in nature conservation, sustainable forestry, and the energy sector, utilizing specific data points (e.g., 40,000 species, 56% habitat status). Reference is made to the work of Professor Metslaid of the Estonian University of Life Sciences and data provided by Tõetamm of "Eesti 2035." Specialized knowledge is also evident in the description of new practices implemented by RMK and the necessity of chemical valorization within the forest industry.

The speaker demonstrates expertise in the field of nature conservation and forestry, citing specific data (11,000 hectares, 0.5% of the total forest area) and the existence of 40,000 species in Estonia. This professional knowledge is based on a thorough understanding of the European infringement procedure and the 2023 report by the State Audit Office, which addressed the permitting of logging in restricted zones. Expert considerations regarding the severe impact of extensive logging on forest habitats are also referenced.

The speaker demonstrates expertise in hunting policy and environmental conservation, referring to the technical necessity of the law amendment (error correction). He emphasizes the exceptionally high level of cooperation between the Estonian state and hunters/hunting associations, claiming that this serves as a model for the whole of Europe.

The speaker demonstrates significant expertise in energy policy and infrastructure, employing technical terminology like "frequency range," "congestion charge," and "dispatchable capacity." Concrete figures are provided for investments (1.6 billion euros) and consumer costs (1 cent/kWh, 13 euros annually for energy supply security). Special emphasis is placed on the role of new capacities, such as a 200 MW battery park, in stabilizing the system.

The speaker demonstrates profound expertise in the energy sector, detailing the technical aspects of island mode operation, the oil shale reserve, and desynchronization. Specific terminology is employed, and concrete financial data is provided, such as the average cost to the household consumer (€13 annually) and the projected cost per kilowatt-hour (up to 0.8 cents). Furthermore, reference is made to investments totaling 1.6 billion euros made in grid development.

The speaker demonstrates great expertise in the fields of spatial design, architecture, and the organization of the living environment, based on their previous 12 years of work as an architecture and design advisor at the Ministry of Culture. They use specific terminology, such as "competence center," and explain the role of the new office as a partner to local municipalities. This knowledge lends authority when explaining the consolidation of services and the added value provided.

The speaker demonstrates deep expertise in the energy sector, addressing both the historical context (oil shale, energy crisis) and future technologies (renewable energy, storage capacity, nuclear energy). Specific terminology, such as "strategic reserve," is employed, and the necessity of a knowledge-based approach is emphasized when developing the long-term vision.

Deep expertise in the fields of energy, productivity, and industrial development. Technical terminology is employed (e.g., correlation, terawatt-hour), and specific industry representatives and events (Taavi Madiberk, energy conferences) are cited to substantiate the arguments.

The speaker demonstrates strong expertise in the field of energy and climate policy, utilizing specific data (e.g., 8.5 TWh consumption, 4.2% of GDP) and referencing economic models and European Union regulations. Specific emphasis is placed on the efficiency and agility aspects of the digital and green transition, as well as the energy trilemma (security of supply, affordability, clean energy). Reference is made to the findings of the European Climate Network report and industry targets (20 TWh).