By Agendas: Tarmo Tamm

There is not enough data.

The speaker demonstrates knowledge of the European Union Emissions Trading System (ETS) Directive and its implementation in maritime shipping. They use specific terminology (CO2 emissions, partial transposition of the Directive) and refer to the equal application of the regulation and an external support mechanism (aid from the Swiss government).

The speaker demonstrates knowledge in the field of banking and financial supervision, focusing on specific regulations concerning the deadlines for closing corporate accounts and the return of funds (three years). They utilize detailed knowledge of banking practices and legal deadlines.

Demonstrates high competence in the transposition of EU climate law and the ETS (Emissions Trading System) Directive, referencing specific regulations and implementing decisions (e.g., the delegated regulation of 12.10.2023). Presents detailed data concerning the obligations and compensation measures imposed on shipping companies (approximately 8 million EUR in levies, 25 million EUR for environmental support). Bases its justifications on the opinions of the Riigikogu Legal and Analysis Department regarding the principles of legitimate expectation and legal certainty.

The speaker demonstrates comprehensive knowledge of the implementation of the EU Emissions Trading System (ETS) in the shipping sector, utilizing specific terminology and data. The presentation includes details on exemptions for ice-class vessels, the mechanism for distributing ETS revenue, and the varying scopes of emission compensation (e.g., 50% versus 100% coverage). Furthermore, concrete financial projections are outlined concerning the cost incurred by the Estonian shipping sector (8 million euros) and the corresponding state revenue (15 million euros).

The speaker demonstrates expertise in the field of hunting and large predator management, using terms such as "nuisance specimens" and referencing the mandates of the Environmental Board. They rely on expert opinion regarding the necessity of culling and present specific data on the damages incurred (over 100,000 euros in damage, 57 cattle killed in Soomaa). Furthermore, they are aware of the procedures for revoking firearm licenses and the subsequent impact this has on national defense.

The speaker demonstrates knowledge of legislative specifics, addressing particular percentage thresholds (50% and 20%). This expertise is linked to committee work and long-term regulatory planning within the financial sector.

The speaker demonstrates expertise regarding public transport regulation and compensation mechanisms, referencing studies that indicate the carrier's loss (45–46% of the ticket price). Technical terminology is employed concerning data verification and retention, emphasizing the necessity of collecting the personal identification codes of eligible individuals and retaining the data for six months.

The speaker demonstrates expertise in the field of environmental and economic statistics, utilizing specific comparative data (CO2 footprint per square kilometer, the state of biodiversity in Europe). They are proficient in topics such as biodiversity, the share of protected areas, and GDP per capita, supporting their arguments with quantitative statements.

The speaker demonstrates expertise regarding public transport regulation, the financial implications of European Court decisions (estimated at 4 million euros), and legislative procedures (the Economic Affairs Committee, first reading). Separate emphasis is placed on the necessity of an IT solution when establishing the compensation payment procedure, highlighting various estimates concerning the time expenditure required.

The speaker demonstrates knowledge of administrative procedures and bureaucracy, referencing the historical context of response deadlines ("keeping pace with stacks of paper"). The emphasis is placed on procedural efficiency and compelling those responsible to focus, thereby avoiding requests for unnecessary additional information. No specific technical or statistical data is used, apart from the deadlines themselves (30 vs 15 days).

The speaker shows interest in macroeconomic planning and long-term growth strategies, addressing the government's ambitious goal of doubling the economy. They turn to an expert to assess the plan's feasibility and get specific recommendations, which suggests a political interest rather than a need for technical, detailed expertise.

The speaker demonstrates expertise in banking and macroeconomic issues, describing banks as the economy's circulatory system and profit as the only self-generating resource for investment. They use economic terminology (e.g., Euribor, minority shareholders) and warn against the precedent of retroactive taxation, which could spread to other sectors and private individuals.

The speaker demonstrates competence regarding legislative procedure and timetables, particularly concerning the ratification of international agreements. He/She speaks authoritatively when explaining the work of the Economic Committee and procedural decisions, utilizing specific terminology such as "deadline for submitting amendments" and "procedural decisions."

The speaker demonstrates expertise in the fields of economic strategy, innovation management, and regulatory reform. Specific terminology is employed, such as "knowledge-intensive industry," "metadata," "the Green Deal," and "business diplomacy." Emphasis is placed on the necessity of establishing a Deputy Secretary General role to promote science-based industry, indicating a profound understanding of the requirements of administrative structures.

The speaker demonstrates knowledge regarding the operational structure of the Economic Committee and the procedures for processing draft legislation. However, direct substantive expertise is absent, as the presentation relies entirely on the comprehensive overview provided by specialists from the Ministry of Climate (the Minister and the Head of Department).