Agenda Profile: Lauri Laats
Second Reading of the Draft Act on the Amendment of the Penal Code and Related Acts (Increase of the Fine Unit) (Bill 415 SE)
2024-06-06
15th Riigikogu, 3rd session, plenary sitting
Political Position
The Centre Party faction is critical of the Reform Party's policy, stressing that the increase in fine rates and the decision to link them to income are problematic and potentially unjust. They highlight the role of local municipalities and express concern about the impact of these fines on residents, seeking to incorporate feedback from local opinions. Furthermore, they are prepared to vote on amendments, but are proceeding cautiously and actively seeking cooperation.
8 Speeches Analyzed
Topic Expertise
Demonstrates knowledge regarding the role of local governments, urban planning, and public transport financing; references Finnish practices and stresses the necessity of supervision and adherence to legality. It is repeatedly pointed out that linking fines to income and oversight by the tax authority are crucial issues. While direct scientific or statistical argumentation is absent, focus is placed on the administrative process and the areas of impact within the public sector.
8 Speeches Analyzed
Rhetorical Style
The tone is formal, proper, and highly cooperative; the speaker frequently utilizes respectful address and questions to engage the colleague in the discussion. The speaker also employs suggestions and a speech pattern that requests pauses, reflecting a style that is reasoned rather than confrontational. Coupled with repeated appeals, the speaker emphasizes collective deliberation and the preparation for votes.
8 Speeches Analyzed
Activity Patterns
He/She was very active during one sitting when various aspects of the same draft bill were being discussed (8 speeches on June 6th). He/She stresses the necessity of arranging breaks and voting time and refers to actions taken on behalf of the faction. This similar focus on procedural execution and timing suggests consistent involvement in the debates surrounding this particular bill.
8 Speeches Analyzed
Opposition Stance
The main opposition focuses on the policies of the Reform Party government, criticizing them particularly regarding the increase in fine rates and the direction of tax revenue flow. The state's funding structure is also criticized, with emphasis placed on the importance of impact and transparency for residents and local municipalities. There is no personal or attack-oriented rhetoric; the criticism remains primarily political and policy-based.
8 Speeches Analyzed
Collaboration Style
Demonstrates readiness for cooperation and compromise, encouraging all colleagues towards a more positive mindset. It emphasizes the importance of finding consensus at the faction level and mentions the need to involve external parties or a benchmate to streamline the process. It focuses very strongly on finding common, non-confrontational solutions.
8 Speeches Analyzed
Regional Focus
Erisuur focuses on the Tallinn region and local governments, referencing the roles of the city district administrations operating within Tallinn. He/She emphasizes the impact generated at the local level and the necessity of involving local structures in the implementation of the draft legislation. The context of Tallinn and local governments remains central to his/her discussions.
8 Speeches Analyzed
Economic Views
From an economic standpoint, the focus is on the economic impact of increasing fine rates and maintaining budgetary continuity. He/She criticizes the practice of filling the state treasury through the collection of taxes or fines, and stresses the necessity of taking into account the burdens placed on residents and local governments. He/She tends to favor a distribution of funding that avoids imposing unnecessary burdens on citizens and does not immediately or directly damage the standard of living.
8 Speeches Analyzed
Social Issues
It confirms that the increase in fines and linking them to income affects the economic situation of the population and may be difficult to afford. It emphasizes social justice and the reduction of the burden on residents, and wishes to take into account the actual needs of local communities. No broad social or cultural policy positions have been presented.
8 Speeches Analyzed
Legislative Focus
The focus is on Bill 415 SE for the second reading and the related amendments (e.g., No. 2), as well as arranging procedural matters for the vote, such as the tenfold or threefold recess. He/She emphasizes the need to discuss and vote on the amendments and refers to the parliamentary faction's desire to lead the process collaboratively. The purpose of the bill is to increase the unit of penalty and amend the corresponding related legislation.
8 Speeches Analyzed