Agenda Profile: Aivar Kokk
First reading of the Draft Resolution of the Riigikogu "Making a Proposal to the Government of the Republic to Abandon the Imposition of the Car Tax and Withdraw the Motor Vehicle Tax Bill from the Riigikogu Proceedings" (374 OE)
2024-04-02
15th Riigikogu, 3rd sitting, plenary sitting
Political Position
The speaker strongly opposes the introduction of the car tax, accusing the governing coalition of deceiving voters, as none of the coalition parties had promised to implement such a tax prior to the elections. They advocate for lowering taxes to stimulate the economy and argue that eliminating the income tax exemption for high earners would resolve budget issues without the need for new taxation. Furthermore, the speaker criticizes the government’s economic policy, claiming that decisions made over the last two years have led the economy into a decline.
4 Speeches Analyzed
Topic Expertise
Displays thorough knowledge in the field of the state budget, the tax system, and economic policy, utilizing specific figures and examples. Demonstrates expert knowledge of the energy sector, detailing the causes behind the rise in electricity and gas prices and their subsequent impact on the economy. References their prior experience as the chairman of the Finance Committee and highlights specific monetary figures concerning the effects of the state's economic decisions.
4 Speeches Analyzed
Rhetorical Style
The speaker employs an emotional and accusatory tone, labeling the government's actions as "lying" and a "steamroller approach" (or "railroading tactic"). They lean heavily on numerical data and concrete examples to substantiate their claims. Rhetorical questions and personal experiences are utilized to reinforce the argument, particularly when discussing the issues facing rural areas and the plight of families.
4 Speeches Analyzed
Activity Patterns
Refers to regular participation in the work of the Finance Committee and the daily morning commute to the Riigikogu. Mentions actively following economic analyses and data from the Statistical Office. Demonstrates continuous engagement with state budget issues and the preparation of the supplementary budget.
4 Speeches Analyzed
Opposition Stance
The text sharply criticizes the current government coalition, specifically targeting the Prime Minister and the Minister of Finance, accusing them of harming the economy and misleading voters. It asserts that the coalition is employing a "steamroller tactic" and violating laws to force through a draft bill requiring 51 votes. The opposition remains principled and uncompromising regarding the car tax issue.
4 Speeches Analyzed
Collaboration Style
They are showing no signs of willingness to cooperate with the current coalition regarding the car tax issue. They point to previous cooperation with the former coalition during the COVID-19 crisis as a positive example. Furthermore, they criticize the limiting of discussions within the Finance Committee, arguing that the opposition is not being allowed to properly defend its viewpoints.
4 Speeches Analyzed
Regional Focus
Strongly emphasizes the issues facing rural areas, arguing that the car tax disproportionately affects rural residents, where public transportation is inadequate or nonexistent. The security aspect is also highlighted, with the argument that concentrating the population in cities undermines national security. The need for people to be able to live throughout Estonia, including in border regions, is stressed.
4 Speeches Analyzed
Economic Views
He advocates for a low tax burden, asserting that no country has ever achieved prosperity by raising taxes. He criticizes the income tax exemption for high earners, calling it an unfair and expensive measure. He supports business-friendly policies and argues that during difficult economic circumstances, taxes should be lowered, not increased. He emphasizes the necessity of maintaining the competitiveness of banks founded on Estonian capital.
4 Speeches Analyzed
Social Issues
It primarily focuses on the economic situation and opportunities available to families, especially those with children. It highlights the problem of accessing healthy food options when rising prices force people to choose cheaper alternatives. It also raises the issue of equal opportunities for residents in rural areas regarding access to education and extracurricular activities.
4 Speeches Analyzed
Legislative Focus
The focus is on activities opposing the motor vehicle tax bill, claiming that it may be in conflict with the constitution and EU law. The legislative process is criticized, with claims that a provision requiring 51 votes was illegally added to the draft legislation. Future discussions concerning teachers' salaries and the supplementary budget are mentioned, demonstrating active monitoring of legislative work.
4 Speeches Analyzed