Agenda Profile: Tanel Kiik
Draft law amending the Competition Act and, in connection therewith, amending other laws (609 SE) - first reading
2025-05-05
15th Riigikogu, 5th session, plenary sitting
Political Position
He criticized the weakening of the competition law, claiming that the amendments serve the interests of oligopolistic companies at the expense of consumers. He accused the government of pandering to the business lobby and demanded a stronger competition policy in the pharmaceutical and fuel sectors.
Topic Expertise
The speaker demonstrated an understanding of the principles of competition law and market economy, citing the threats posed by the oligopolistic market and the lessons learned from the pharmacy reform. Specific examples were used regarding the conduct of wholesalers in 2019.
Rhetorical Style
Used sharp criticism and leveled accusations concerning the business lobby. Combined personal experiences as Minister of Health with fact-based arguments regarding the necessity of competition.
Activity Patterns
He/She actively participated in the discussion of economic and competition issues, raising several consecutive questions and comments. He/She repeatedly referred to his/her previous experience as Minister of Health.
Opposition Stance
He accused the government of catering to business lobbying interests while weakening the Competition Act. He claimed that the amendments serve the interests of oligopolistic companies at the expense of consumers and undermine fair competition.
Collaboration Style
The speaker demonstrated a constructive approach, acknowledging the minister's analytical capacity while simultaneously offering critical feedback. The style was professional and evidence-based, actively seeking opportunities for dialogue.
Regional Focus
He criticized the government’s decision to start exporting prison services, questioning the effect this would have on Estonia’s reputation. He focused on national priorities.
Economic Views
Criticizes the amendments to the Competition Act as being driven by business interests. Supports a stronger competition policy and increasing the capacity of the Competition Authority.
Social Issues
He/She criticized the government's plan to start exporting prison services, raising questions about its potential impact on Estonia's reputation and security.
Legislative Focus
He criticized the amendments to the Competition Act, characterizing them as serving narrow business interests. He argued that the original, stronger version would have better protected consumer interests and ensured fairer competition.